Selecting Models

Overview

The large language model (LLM) is the core intelligence of your agent system. It's responsible for understanding instructions, reasoning about problems, and generating responses. The model you choose will significantly impact your agent's capabilities, performance, and cost-effectiveness.

Different models have different strengths, weaknesses, and specializations. Understanding these differences is crucial for selecting the right model for your specific use case.

Model Types

LLMs can be categorized in several ways, each with implications for your agent design:

General-Purpose vs. Specialized Models +

General-Purpose Models: Trained on broad datasets to handle a wide range of tasks. Examples include GPT-4, Claude, and Llama 2.

  • Pros: Versatility, broad knowledge, good reasoning capabilities
  • Cons: May not excel at highly specialized tasks, potentially higher cost

Specialized Models: Fine-tuned for specific domains or tasks. Examples include models specialized for code generation, medical knowledge, or legal analysis.

  • Pros: Superior performance in their domain, potentially more efficient
  • Cons: Limited versatility, may struggle with tasks outside their specialty
Size and Complexity +

Large Models: Models with more parameters (typically tens or hundreds of billions). Examples include GPT-4 and Claude 2.

  • Pros: Superior reasoning, better handling of complex tasks, more robust
  • Cons: Higher computational requirements, higher cost, potentially slower

Medium/Small Models: Models with fewer parameters. Examples include Llama 2 7B, Mistral 7B.

  • Pros: Lower cost, faster inference, can run on less powerful hardware
  • Cons: May struggle with complex reasoning, less robust for challenging tasks
Hosted vs. Self-Hosted +

Hosted Models: Accessed through API providers like OpenAI, Anthropic, or cloud platforms.

  • Pros: No infrastructure management, easy scaling, access to cutting-edge models
  • Cons: Ongoing API costs, potential data privacy concerns, dependency on provider

Self-Hosted Models: Run on your own infrastructure.

  • Pros: Full control over data and infrastructure, potentially lower long-term costs
  • Cons: Requires technical expertise, infrastructure investment, may have access to fewer cutting-edge models

Selection Criteria

When evaluating models for your agent, consider these key factors:

Reasoning Capabilities

How well can the model break down complex problems, follow multi-step instructions, and handle abstract concepts?

Context Window Size

How much information can the model process at once? Larger context windows allow for more complex interactions and better memory.

Domain Knowledge

Does the model have specialized knowledge relevant to your use case (e.g., coding, medicine, finance)?

Tool Use Proficiency

How effectively can the model use external tools and APIs? Some models are better at understanding and generating structured outputs.

Performance Metrics

Response time, throughput, and reliability considerations for your specific deployment scenario.

Cost Structure

Per-token pricing, volume discounts, and overall cost implications for your expected usage patterns.

Key Tradeoffs

Model selection often involves balancing competing priorities:

Capability vs. Cost

More capable models typically come with higher costs, both in terms of API pricing and computational requirements.

Considerations:

  • Will the enhanced capabilities justify the increased cost?
  • Can you use a more capable model for complex tasks and a simpler model for routine operations?
  • How does the model cost compare to the value generated or human time saved?

Strategy:

Consider a tiered approach where you use different models for different parts of your agent system based on the complexity requirements of each component.

Speed vs. Quality

Faster models often sacrifice some level of reasoning capability or output quality.

Considerations:

  • How time-sensitive are your agent's tasks?
  • Would users prefer faster but potentially less perfect responses?
  • Can you implement caching or other optimization strategies?

Strategy:

For interactive applications, consider using faster models for initial responses and more capable models for complex follow-ups or background processing.

Control vs. Convenience

Self-hosted models offer more control but require more technical expertise and infrastructure management.

Considerations:

  • How important is data privacy and sovereignty for your use case?
  • Do you have the technical resources to manage model infrastructure?
  • What are your scaling requirements?

Strategy:

Consider a hybrid approach where sensitive operations use self-hosted models while more general tasks leverage hosted APIs.

Best Practices

Follow these guidelines to make effective model selection decisions:

Start with Clear Requirements +

Before evaluating models, clearly define:

  • The specific tasks your agent needs to perform
  • Performance requirements (response time, throughput)
  • Budget constraints
  • Specialized knowledge or capabilities needed

Having clear requirements will help you narrow down your options and focus on the most relevant factors.

Conduct Comparative Testing +

Don't rely solely on published benchmarks or specifications:

  • Test multiple models with your specific use cases
  • Create a representative test set that covers your expected scenarios
  • Evaluate both quantitative metrics and qualitative aspects
  • Consider A/B testing with real users if possible

Direct comparison is the most reliable way to determine which model works best for your specific needs.

Consider a Multi-Model Approach +

You don't have to commit to a single model for all operations:

  • Use specialized models for specific tasks where they excel
  • Implement fallback mechanisms between models
  • Route requests to different models based on complexity or requirements
  • Consider ensemble approaches for critical decisions

A thoughtfully designed multi-model architecture can provide better performance and cost-effectiveness than relying on a single model.

Plan for Evolution +

The LLM landscape is rapidly evolving:

  • Design your architecture to accommodate model switching
  • Regularly reassess model performance against newer alternatives
  • Monitor usage patterns and costs to optimize selection over time
  • Stay informed about new model capabilities and pricing changes

Building flexibility into your system will allow you to take advantage of improvements in model technology as they become available.

Test Your Understanding

Which factor is most important to consider when selecting a model for an agent that needs to perform complex reasoning tasks?

  • Response speed
  • Reasoning capabilities
  • Model size in gigabytes
  • Release date

What is a key advantage of using specialized models over general-purpose models?

  • They always cost less
  • They have larger context windows
  • They perform better in their specific domain
  • They are more versatile across different tasks

Which approach is recommended when selecting models for an agent system?

  • Always choose the largest model available
  • Rely exclusively on published benchmarks
  • Select a single model for all operations
  • Conduct comparative testing with your specific use cases
← Agent Design Defining Tools →